Choosing Your Own Path: A Music-School Memory

Originally published April 19, 2021; updated November 11, 2026. This is a personal memory, not a general rule about music education.
When I was a child, I wanted to learn guitar. At music school, I was told my fingers were too short, so I was placed in accordion lessons instead. I studied accordion for more than three years, along with music theory, piano and singing. All that time, guitar was the instrument I had wanted to try.
What I was told—and what I later wondered
When I tell people this story now, they often say my fingers look perfectly ordinary. Years later, I began to wonder whether the guitar class was simply full and the accordion class had space. That is my later guess, not something I can prove about the school’s decision. What I do know is that the explanation I heard changed the path I took.
Why I did not finish music school
I left two years before completing the program. I never grew to like playing accordion, and today I cannot remember how to play it. I do not regret learning about music, but I wish I had been able to explore the instrument that interested me in the first place.
A choice I can still revisit
When I wrote this note in 2021, I was thinking about taking guitar lessons. That was an intention, not a claim that I had already begun. The memory reminds me to ask questions when an answer does not fit what I want to learn, and to look for another route before giving up on an interest.
Other people’s advice may be useful. Their first decision for you does not have to be your final one.



